Andrew M. Casey
Meet Andrew
Andy Casey is a founding partner of Hendrick, Casey, & Hutter. Andy first teamed up with Seth Hendrick in late 2019 and cemented their place as one of the top criminal defense teams in the state. Starting in February of 2022, the duo added Andrew Hutter to round out the group with Hutter’s lengthy experience and calm cool demeanor.
Andy Casey’s role revolves around cases that are complex or have stiff resistance. In one single twelve month period from June 2021 through June 2022, Andy led the fight as first-chair in six separate jury trials leading to several favorable outcomes for his clients. In his career, Andy prevailed at jury trials in federal, state, and tribal courts across the State of Oklahoma. If push comes to shove, HCH always has Andy Casey available to effectively pursue a trial for your rights.
In addition to trial practice, Andy began his career as a distinguished appeal attorney who prevailed in appeals at the Supreme Court of Oklahoma, the Oklahoma Court of Civil Appeals, the Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals, and the Tenth Circuit Federal Court of Appeals in Denver, CO.
Below are two oral arguments that were completed by Andrew Casey. In Burke v. Holdman, Andy convinced the appellate panel to reverse a district court's dismissal of his client's claim against a doctor for medical malpractice. In Reavis v. Frost, the appellate court published an opinion in Andy's client's favor that ultimately led to a favorable settlement for our client.
One final practice area involves Andy’s judicial service. In 2022, the Quapaw Nation of Oklahoma formally appointed Andrew M. Casey as a District Court judge for the tribe’s reservation in Miami, OK.
Andrew grew up in the Sand Springs, OK area before graduating from Jenks High School and obtained a Bachelor's Degree from the University of Central Oklahoma as well as attending graduate school at the University of Oklahoma.
During undergraduate school, Andrew excelled at College Policy Debate qualifying for elimination rounds at the most prestigious debate tournaments in the nation. After graduating, Andrew began his first career in teaching and coaching within the Policy Debate program at the University of North Texas in Denton, TX as well as Heritage Hall in Oklahoma City, OK.
Eventually, Andrew enrolled at the University of Oklahoma College of Law becoming an Editor for the American Indian Law Review, competing at the National NALSA Moot Court Competition, and working at numerous internships ranging from the Department of Justice in Washington D.C. to a non-profit legal service representing low-income Native American clients.
After graduating law school, Andrew started his legal career the Tulsa area before moving to Oklahoma City to continue his career and finally found Hendrick, Casey, & Hutter.
-
Phone: (405) 232-1515
Email: Casey@hchokc.com
-
Federal Criminal Defense
State Criminal Defense
Appeals
Post-Conviction Relief
Civil Rights and Employment law
Tribal Representation
-
U.S. District Court Eastern District of Oklahoma
U.S. District Court Northern District of Oklahoma
U.S. District Court Western District of Oklahoma
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit
Supreme Court of Oklahoma, All Oklahoma County Courts
Supreme Court of Cherokee Nation
Supreme Court of Chickasaw Nation
Supreme Court of Muscogee (Creek) Nation
Supreme Court of Quapaw Nation
-
University of Oklahoma College of Law, Norman, Oklahoma
University of Central Oklahoma, B.A. Bachelor of Arts, Major: Political Science
Juris Doctor - 2015
Honors: National NALSA Moot Court Team, 2014 and 2015
Honors: Top Speaker/Best Oralist, 2014 National NALSA Moot Court Championship
Honors: Elite Eight, 2015 National NALSA Moot Court Championship
Honors: Board of Advocates
Law Review: American Indian Law Review, Articles Development Editor
-
Oklahoma Bar Association, Member
Oklahoma Bar Association Mock Trial Committee, Committee Member
Oklahoma Bar Association, Leadership Class of 2018
Oklahoma Bar Association, Rules, and Professional Conduct Committee
Oklahoma Bar Association, Law Day Committee
-
United States Department of Justice in Washington, D.C., Intern
Honorable Judge Daman Cantrell in Tulsa County, OK, Intern
Tulsa County District Attorney's Office, Intern
Hobbs, Straus, Dean & Walker in Downtown Oklahoma City, Intern
Foshee & Yaffe, in Oklahoma City, Intern
Law Office of Gary S. Pitchlynn in Norman, OK, Intern
Price & Sears, P.C. Claremore, OK, Associate Attorney
Stinnett Law, Sapulpa, OK, Associate Attorney
Foshee & Yaffe, Associate Attorney
-
Former Member, Board of Directors, Show, Inc. in Sapulpa, OK
Andy has litigated a number of cases for free as pro bono service to the Oklahoma community
Get in Touch with Andrew M. Casey
